Oclaro’s 400-gigabit plans
Adam Carter, Oclaro’s chief commercial officer, discusses the company’s 400-gigabit and higher-speed coherent optical transmission plans and the 400-gigabit client-side pluggable opportunity.
Oclaro showcased its first coherent module that uses Ciena’s WaveLogic Ai digital signal processor at the ECOC show held recently in Gothenburg.
Adam CarterOclaro is one of three optical module makers, the others being Lumentum and NeoPhotonics, that signed an agreement with Ciena earlier this year to use the system vendor’s DSP technology and know-how to bring coherent modules to market. The first product resulting from the collaboration is a 5x7-inch board-mounted module that supports 400-gigabits on a single-wavelength.
The first WaveLogic Ai-based modules are already being tested at several of Oclaro’s customers’ labs. “They [the module samples] are very preliminary,” says Adam Carter, the chief commercial officer at Oclaro. “The really important timeframe is when we get towards the new year because then we will have beta samples.”
DSP developments
The coherent module is a Ciena design and Carter admits there isn’t going to be much differentiation between the three module makers’ products.
“We have some of the key components that sit inside that module and the idea is, over time, we would design in the rest of the componentry that we make that isn’t already in there,” says Carter. “But it is still going to be the same spec between the three suppliers.”
The collaboration with the module makers helps Ciena promote its coherent DSP to a wider market and in particular China, a market where its systems are not deployed.
Over time, the scope for differentiation between the three module makers will grow. “It [the deal] gives us access to another DSP chip for potential future applications,” says Carter.
Here, Oclaro will be the design authority, procuring the DSP chip for Ciena before adding its own optics. “So, for example, for the [OIF’s] 400G ZR, we would ask Ciena to develop a chip to a certain spec and then put our optical sub-assemblies around it,” says Carter. “This is where we do believe we can differentiate.”
Oclaro also unveiled at ECOC an integrated coherent transmitter and an intradyne coherent receiver optical sub-assemblies using its indium phosphide technology that operate at up to 64 gigabaud (Gbaud).
We expect to see 64Gbaud optical systems being trialed in 2018 with production systems following at the end of next year
A 64Gbaud symbol rate enables a 400-gigabit wavelength using 16-ary quadrature amplitude modulation (16-QAM) and a 600-gigabit wavelength using 64-QAM.
Certain customers want such optical sub-assemblies for their line card designs and Oclaro will also use the building blocks for its own modules. The devices will be available this quarter. “We expect to see 64Gbaud optical systems being trialed in 2018 with production systems following at the end of next year and the beginning of 2019,” says Carter.
Oclaro also announced that its lithium niobate modulator supporting 400-gigabit single wavelengths is now in volume production. “Certain customers do have their preferences when it comes to first designs and particularly for long-reach systems,” says Carter. “Lithium niobate seems to be the one people go with.”
400-gigabit form factors
Oclaro did not make any announcements regarding 400-gigabit client-side modules at ECOC. At the OFC show held earlier this year, it detailed two CFP8-based 400-gigabit designs based on eight wavelengths with reaches of 10km and 40km.
“We are sampling the 400-gigabit 10km product right now,” says Carter. “The product is being tested at the system level and will go through various qualification runs.”
The 40km CFP8 product is further out. There are customers interested in such a module as they have requirements to link IP routers that are more than 10km apart.
Carter describes the CFP8 400-gigabit modules as first-generation products. The CFP8 is similar in size to the CFP2 pluggable module and that is too large for the large-scale data centre players. They want higher aggregate bandwidth and greater front panel densities for their switches and are looking such form factors as the double-density QSFP (QSFP-DD) and the Octal Small Form Factor pluggable (OSFP).
The OSFP is a fresh design, has a larger power envelope - some 15W compared to the 12W of the QSFP-DD - and has a roadmap that supports 800-gigabit data rates. In contrast, the QSFP-DD is backward compatible with the QSFP, an attractive feature for many vendors.
But it is not only a module’s power envelope that is an issue for 400-gigabit designs but also whether a one-rack-unit box can be sufficiently cooled when fully populated to avoid thermal runaway. Some 36 QSFP-DDs can fit on the front panel compared to 32 OSFPs.
Carter stresses both form factors can’t be dismissed for 400-gigabit: “Everyone is pursuing designs that are suitable for both.” Oclaro is not an advocate of either form factor given it provides optical sub-assemblies suitable for both.
The industry really wants four-channels. When you use more lasers, you are adding more cost.
Optical formats
Oclaro’s core technology is indium phosphide and, as such, its focusses on single-mode fibre designs.
The single mode options for 400 gigabits are split between eight-wavelength designs such as the IEEE 802.3bs 2km 400GBASE-FR8 and 10km 400GBASE-LR8 and the newly announced CWDM8 MSA, and four-wavelength specifications - the 500m IEEE 802.3bs parallel fibre 400GBASE-DR4 and the 2km 100G Lambda MSA 400G-FR4 that is under development. Oclaro is a founding member of the 100 Gigabit Lambda MSA but has not joined the CWDM8 MSA.
"The industry really wants four channels," says Carter. "When you use more lasers, you are adding more cost." It is also not trivial fitting eight lasers into a CFP8 never mind into the smaller QSFP-DD and OSFP modules.
“There might be some that have the technology to do the eight-channel part and there might be customers that will use that,” says Carter. “But most of the discussions we’ve been having are around four channels.”
Challenges
The industry’s goal is to have 400-gigabit QSFP-DD and OSFP module in production by the end of next year and into 2019. “There is still some risk but everybody is driving to meet that schedule,” says Carter.
Oclaro says first samples of 100-gigabit PAM-4 chips needed for 100-gigabit single wavelengths are now in the labs. Module makers can thus add their optical sub-assemblies to the chips and start testing system performance. Four-channel PAM-4 chips will be needed for the 400-gigabit module products.
Carter also acknowledges that any further delay in four-wavelength designs could open the door for other 400-gigabit solutions and even interim 200-gigabit designs.
“As a transceiver supplier and an optical component supplier you are always aware of that,” he says. “You have to have backup plans if that comes off.”
Merits and challenges of optical transmission at 64 Gbaud
u2t Photonics announced recently a balanced detector that supports 64Gbaud. This promises coherent transmission systems with double the data rate. But even if the remaining components - the modulator and DSP-ASIC capable of operating at 64Gbaud - were available, would such an approach make sense?
Gazettabyte asked system vendors Transmode and Ciena for their views.
Transmode:
Transmode points out that 100 Gigabit dual-polarisation, quadrature phase-shift keying (DP-QPSK) using coherent detection has several attractive characteristics as a modulation format.
It can be used in the same grid as 10 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) and 40Gbps signals in the C-band. It also has a similar reach as 10Gbps by achieving a comparable optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR). Moreover, it has superior tolerance to chromatic dispersion and polarisation mode dispersion (PMD), enabling easier network design, especially with meshed networking.
The IEEE has started work standardising the follow-on speed of 400 Gigabit. "This is a reasonable step since it will be possible to design optical transmission systems at 400 Gig with reasonable performance and cost," says Ulf Persson, director of network architecture in Transmode's CTO office.
Moving to 100Gbps was a large technology jump that involved advanced technologies such as high-speed analogue-to-digital (A/D) converters and advanced digital signal processing, says Transmode. But it kept the complexity within the optical transceivers which could be used with current optical networks. It also enabled new network designs due to the advanced chromatic dispersion and PMD compensations made possible by the coherent technology and the DSP-ASIC.
For 400Gbps, the transition will be simpler. "Going from 100 Gig to 400 Gig will re-use a lot of the technologies used for 100 Gig coherent," says Magnus Olson, director of hardware engineering.
So even if there will be some challenges with higher-speed components, the main challenge will move from the optical transceivers to the network, he says. That is because whatever modulation format is selected for 400Gbps, it will not be possible to fit that signal into current networks keeping both the current channel plan and the reach.
"From an industry point of view, a metro-centric cost reduction of 100Gbps coherent is currently more important than increasing the bit rate to 400Gbps"
"If you choose a 400 Gigabit single carrier modulation format that fits into a 50 Gig channel spacing, the optical performance will be rather poor, resulting in shorter transmission distances," says Persson. Choosing a modulation format that has a reasonable optical performance will require a wider passband. Inevitably there will be a tradeoff between these two parameters, he says.
This will likely lead to different modulation formats being used at 400 Gig, depending on the network application targeted. Several modulation formats are being investigated, says Transmode, but the two most discussed are:
- 4x100Gbps super-channels modulated with DP-QPSK. This is the same as today's modulation format with the same optical performance as 100Gbps, and requires a channel width of 150GHz.
- 2x200Gbps super-channels, modulated with DP-16-QAM. This will have a passband of about 75GHz. It is also possible to put each of the two channels in separate 50GHz-spaced channels and use existing networks The effective bandwidth will then be 100GHz for a 400GHz signal. However, the OSNR performance for this format is about 5-6 dB worse than the 100Gbps super-channels. That equates to about a quarter of the reach at 100Gbps.
As a result, 100Gbps super-channels are more suited to long distance systems while 200Gbps super-channels are applicable to metro/ regional systems.
Since 200Gbps super-channels can use standard 50GHz spacing, they can be used in existing metro networks carrying a mix of traffic including 10Gbps and 40Gbps light paths.
"Both 400 Gig alternatives mentioned have a baud rate of about 32 Gig and therefore do not require a 64 Gbaud photo detector," says Olson. "If you want to go to a single channel 400G with 16-QAM or 32-QAM modulation, you will get 64Gbaud or 51Gbaud rate and then you will need the 64 Gig detector."
The single channel formats, however, have worse OSNR performance than 200Gbps super-channels, about 10-12 dB worse than 100Gbps, says Transmode, and have a similar spectral efficiency as 200Gbps super-channels. "So it is not the most likely candidates for 400 Gig," says Olson. "It is therefore unclear for us if this detector will have a use in 400 Gigabit transmission in the near future."
Transmode points out that the state-of-the-art bit rate has traditionally been limited by the available optics. This has kept the baud rate low by using higher order modulation formats that support more bits per symbol to enable existing, affordable technology to be used.
"But the price you have to pay, as you can not fool physics, is shorter reach due to the OSNR penalty," says Persson.
Now the challenges associated with the DSP-ASIC development will be equally important as the optics to further boost capacity.
The bundling of optical carriers into super-channels is an approach that scales well beyond what can be accomplished with improved optics. "Again, we have to pay the price, in this case eating greater portions of the spectrum," says Persson.
Improving the bandwidth of the balanced detector to the extent done by u2t is a very impressive achievement. But it will not make it alone into new products, modulators and a faster DSP-ASIC will also be required.
"From an industry point of view, a metro-centric cost reduction of 100Gbps coherent is currently more important than increasing the bit rate to 400Gbps," says Olson. "When 100 Gig coherent costs less than 10x10 Gig, both in dollars and watts, the technology will have matured to again allow for scaling the bit rate, using technology that suits the application best."
Ciena:
How the optical performance changes going from 32Gbaud to 64Gbaud depends largely on how well the DSP-ASIC can mitigate the dispersion penalties that get worse with speed as the duration of a symbol narrows.
BPSK goes twice as far as QPSK which goes about 4.5 times as far as 16-QAM
"I would also expect a higher sensitivity would be needed also, so another fundamental impact," says Joe Berthold, vice president of network architecture at Ciena. "We have quite a bit or margin with the WaveLogic 3 [DSP-ASIC] for many popular network link distances, so it may not be a big deal."
With a good implementation of a coherent transmission system, the reach is primarily a function of the modulation format. BPSK goes twice as far as QPSK which goes about 4.5 times as far as 16-QAM, says Berthold.
"On fibres without enough dispersion, a higher baud rate will go 25 percent further than the same modulation format at half of that baud rate, due to the nonlinear propagation effects," says Berthold. This is the opposite of what occurred at 10 Gigabit incoherent. On fibres with plenty of local dispersion, the difference becomes marginal, approximately 0.05 dB, according to Ciena.
Regarding how spectral efficiency changes with symbol rate, doubling the baud rate doubles the spectral occupancy, says Berthold, so the benefit of upping the baud rate is that fewer components are needed for a super-channel.
"Of course if the cost of the higher speed components are higher this benefit could be eroded," he says. "So the 200 Gbps signal using DP-QPSK at 64 Gbaud would nominally require 75GHz of spectrum given spectral shaping that we have available in WaveLogic 3, but only require one laser."
Does Ciena have an view as to when 64Gbaud systems will be deployed in the network?
Berthold says this hard to answer. "It depends on expectations that all elements of the signal path, from modulators and detectors to A/D converters, to DSP circuitry, all work at twice the speed, and you get this speedup for free, or almost."
The question has two parts, he says: When could it be done? And when will it provide a significant cost advantage? "As CMOS geometries narrow, components get faster, but mask sets get much more expensive," says Berthold.
u2t Photonics pushes balanced detectors to 70GHz
- u2t's 70GHz balanced detector supports 64Gbaud for test and measurement and R&D
- The company's gallium arsenide modulator and next-generation receiver will enable 100 Gigabit long-haul in a CFP2
"The performance [of gallium arsenide] is very similar to the lithium niobate modulator"
Jens Fiedler, u2t Photonics
u2t Photonics has announced a balanced detector that operates at 70GHz. Such a bandwidth supports 64 Gigabaud (Gbaud), twice the symbol rate of existing 100 Gigabit coherent optical transmission systems.
The German company announced a coherent photo-detector capable of 64Gbaud in 2012 but that had an operating bandwidth of 40GHz. The latest product uses two 70GHz photo-detectors and different packaging to meet the higher bandwidth requirements.
"The achieved performance is a result of R&D work using our experience with 100GHz single photo-detectors and balanced detector technology at a lower speed,” says Jens Fiedler, executive vice president sales and marketing at u2t Photonics.
The monolithically-integrated balanced detector has been sampling since March. The markets for the device are test and measurement systems and research and development (R&D). "It will enable engineers to work on higher-speed interface rates for system development," says Fiedler.
The balanced detector could be used in next-generation transmission systems operating at 64 Gbaud, doubling the current 100 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) data rate while using the same dual-polarisation, quadrature phase-shift keying (DP-QPSK) architecture.
A 64Gbaud DP-QPSK coherent system would halve the number of super-channels needed for 400Gbps and 1 Terabit transmissions. In turn, using 16-QAM instead of QPSK would further halve the channel count - a single dual-polarisation, 16-QAM at 64Gbaud would deliver 400Gbps, while three channels would deliver 1.2Tbps.
However, for such a system to be deployed commercially the remaining components - the modulator, device drivers and the DSP-ASIC - would need to be able to operate at twice the 32Gbaud rate; something that is still several years out. That said, Fiedler points out that the industry is also investigating baud rates in between 32 Gig and 64 Gig.
Gallium arsenide modulator
u2t acquired gallium arsenide modulator technology in June 2009, enabling the company to offer coherent transmitter as well as receiver components.
At OFC/NFOEC 2013, u2t Photonics published a paper on its high-speed gallium arsenide coherent modulator. The company's design is based on the Mach-Zehnder modulator specification of the Optical Internetworking Forum (OIF) for 100 Gigabit DP-QPSK applications.
The DP-QPSK optical modulation includes a rotator on one arm and a polarisation beam combiner at the output. u2t has decided to support an OIF compatible design with a passive polarisation rotator and combiner which could also be integrated on chip. The resulting coherent modulator is now being tested before being integrated with the free space optics to create a working design.
"The performance [of gallium arsenide] is very similar to the lithium niobate modulator," says Fiedler. "Major system vendors have considered the technology for their use and that is still ongoing."
The gallium arsenide modulator is considerably smaller than the equivalent lithium niobate design. Indeed u2t expects the technology's power and size requirements, along with the company's coherent receiver, to fit within the CFP2 optical module. Such a pluggable 100 Gigabit coherent module would meet long-haul requirements, says Fiedler.
The gallium arsenide modulator can also be used within the existing line-side 100 Gigabit 5x7-inch MSA coherent transponder. Fiedler points out that by meeting the OIF specification, there is no space saving benefit using gallium arsenide since both modulator technologies fit within the same dimensioned package. However, the more integrated gallium arsenide modulator may deliver a cost advantage, he says.
Another benefit of using a gallium arsenide modulator is its optical performance stability with temperature. "It requires some [temperature] control but it is stable," says Fiedler.
Coherent receiver
u2t's current 100Gbps coherent receiver product uses two chips, each comprising the 90-degree hybrid and a balanced detector. "That is our current design and it is selling in volume," says Fiedler. "We are now working on the next version, according to the OIF specification, which is size-reduced."
The resulting single-chip design will cost less and fit within a CFP2 pluggable module.
The receiver might be small enough to fit within the even smaller CFP4 module, concludes Fiedler.