Alcatel-Lucent demos dual-carrier Terabit transmission
"Without [photonic] integration you are doubling up your expensive opto-electronic components which doesn't scale"
Peter Winzer, Alcatel-Lucent's Bell Labs
Part 1: Terabit optical transmission
Alcatel-Lucent's research arm, Bell Labs, has used high-speed electronics to enable one Terabit long-haul optical transmission using two carriers only.
Several system vendors have demonstrated one Terabit transmission including Alcatel-Lucent but the company is claiming an industry first in using two multiplexed carriers only. In 2009, Alcatel-Lucent's first Terabit optical transmission used 24 sub-carriers.
"There is a tradeoff between the speed of electronics and the number of optical modulators and detectors you need," says Peter Winzer, director of optical transmission systems and networks research at Bell Labs. "In general it will be much cheaper doing it with fewer carriers at higher electronics speeds than doing it at a lower speed with many more carriers."
What has been done
In the lab-based demonstration, Bell Labs sent five, 1 Terabit-per-second (Tbps) signals over an equivalent distance of 3,200km. Each signal uses dual-polarisation 16-QAM (quadrature amplitude modulation) to achieve a 1.28Tbps signal. Thus each carrier holds 640Gbps: some 500Gbps data and the rest forward error correction (FEC) bits.
In current 100Gbps systems, dual-polarisation, quadrature phase-shift keying (DP-QPSK) modulation is used. Going from QPSK to 16-QAM doubles the bit rate. Bell Labs has also increased the symbol rate from some 30Gbaud to 80Gbaud using state-of-the-art high-speed electronics developed at Alcatel Thales III-V Lab.
"To achieve these rates, you need special high-speed components - multiplexers - and also high-speed multi-level devices," says Winzer. These are indium phosphide components, not CMOS and hence will not be deployed in commercial products for several years yet. "These things are realistic [in CMOS], just not for immediate product implementation," says Winzer.
Each carrier occupies 100GHz of channel bandwidth equating to 200GHz overall, or a 5.2b/s/Hz spectral efficiency. Current state-of-the-art 100Gbps systems use 50GHz channels, achieving 2b/s/Hz.
The 3,200km reach using 16-QAM technology is achieved in the lab, using good fibre and without any commercial product margins, says Winzer. Adding commercial product margins would reduce the optical link budget by 2-3dB and hence the overall reach.
Winzer says the one Terabit demonstration uses all the technologies employed in Alcatel-Lucent's photonic service engine (PSE) ASIC although the algorithms and soft-decision FEC used are more advanced, as expected in an R&D trial.
Before such one Terabit systems become commercial, progress in photonic integration will be needed as well as advances in CMOS process technology.
"Progress in photonic integration is needed to get opto-electronic costs down as it [one Terabit] is still going to need two-to-four sub-carriers," he says. A balance between parallelism and speed needs to be struck, and parallelism is best achieved using integration. "Without integration you are doubling up your expensive opto-electronic components which doesn't scale," says WInzer.
Optical components enter an era of technology-pull
Gazettabyte asked ADVA Optical Networking, Ciena, Cisco Systems and Ovum about their impressions following the recent OFC/NFOEC 2012 exhibition and conference.
OFC/NFOEC reflections: Part 2
"As the economy continues to navigate its way through yet another very difficult period, it was good to see so many companies innovating and introducing solutions."
Massimo Prati, Cisco Systems
Massimo Prati, Cisco Systems
For Cisco Systems, 100 Gigabit was a key focus at the show. "There were many system and component vendors, including Cisco, demonstrating newly available, economically feasible 100 Gig innovations," says Massimo Prati, vice president and general manager for Cisco.
Linking data centres was another conference theme. "Inter-data centre connectivity continues to focus on scalable and simple solutions in long-haul and metro networks connecting data centres worldwide." Cisco believes metro 100 Gigabit deployments will become prevalent in 2013 and 2014, especially if low‐cost coherent technology becomes available.
"A dedicated workshop focused on data centre architectures, held on the first day of the conference, was heavily attended," says Prati. "So certainly the link between cloud and optical is being established and is a key driver for high-speed transport networks."
Another conference theme was interconnect within the data centre, and the need for photonic integration for low‐cost, low‐power links, says Prati: "From a Cisco standpoint, several of our customers were pleasantly surprised by our recently completed acquisition of Lightwire, which develops advanced optical interconnect technology for high-speed networking applications." Lightwire is a silicon photonics startup that Cisco acquired recently for US $271 million.
What Cisco says it learned from OFC/ NFOEC was that service providers are planning 100Gbps deployments within the next 12 months and are looking at second- and third-generation solutions. "There is quite a bit of energy around future upgrades to 400 Gig and one Terabit transport solutions, but service providers continue to monitor if and how these solutions will operate within their existing fibre plants."
Prati expects more industry consolidation. "With the influx of 100 Gig solutions, it appears we may be ripe for further consolidation within the industry, particularly further down the technology food chain," he says.
He also remains optimistic about the industry's prospects.
"We believe that the excitement around high-speed, long-haul transport, combined with cloud and data centre innovation, continues to fuel a lot of new product solutions and architectures," he says. "Content providers like Google and Facebook have clearly expressed interest in optical technologies addressing their issues with bandwidth demands and need for high-speed interconnect for their data centres."
Joe Berthold, Ciena
Whereas last year there was much discussion about of the next rate for Ethernet - 400 Gig or one Terabit - this year 400 Gigabit had most mindshare, says Joe Berthold, vice president of network architecture at Ciena. "I barely heard any mention of one Terabit in the context of a contest with 400 Gigabit," he says.
"I could hear some rumblings about alternative form factors – which might lead to fragmentation of the market"
Joe Berthold, Ciena
400 Gigabit was given a boost with the line-side transmission component announcements. Ciena announced its WaveLogic3 and Alcatel-Lucent detailed its Photonic Service Engine.
Another noteworthy development was the buzz around silicon photonics, stirred in part by Cisco's Lightwire acquisition. "Silicon photonics has passed from a technology of research interest to one that has progressed to serious development," says Berthold. "Data centre interconnects look like a promising initial application."
There was no developments at the show that surprised Berthold. But he is concerned about the potential for proliferation of 100 Gigabit client-side form factors, especially for pluggable modules.
"I am going under the assumption that there is still broad industry support for the CFP progression - from the current CFP to a CFP2 followed by a CFP4 for single-mode fiber applications over metro distances," he says.
Even though there are a variety of technologies appearing in the CFP form factor, this common physical module has helped control system development cost. "I could hear some rumblings about alternative form factors – which might lead to fragmentation of the market," he says.
Berthold is encouraged by the broad base of development efforts underway, particularly for 100Gbps transceivers, but also lower-cost 10Gbps and 40Gbps client-side modules. He notes the progress in reducing the cost of 100 Gigabit client interfaces over the next year. "Their high cost has held back adoption of 100 Gig," says Berthold. "We have had very cost effective 10 Gig multiplexing technology to fall back on, but it looks like native 100G interfaces are poised for growth."
Jörg-Peter Elbers, ADVA Optical Networking
Jörg-Peter Elbers, vice president, advanced technology at ADVA Optical Networking, was struck by the wide range of hot topics discussed at the show.
These include software-defined optics based on programmable transceivers that use advanced DSP technology and flexgrid ROADMs as the basis of a new coherent express layer. He also notes that control plane technologies are becoming an essential asset in managing network complexity when unleashing untapped network capacity.
"Traffic and content keeps growing at exponential scale - the fundamental demand-drivers are intact"
Jörg-Peter Elbers, ADVA Optical Networking
Meanwhile, the rapid increase in end-user traffic, specifically mobile, is driving PON. As a result WDM is moving closer to the network edge, entering aggregation and access networks. He believes dense WDM-PON is gaining traction for mobile backhaul as fibre becomes the bottleneck when moving from Long Term Evolution (LTE) to the LTE-Advanced cellular technology.
Other trends to note, he says, are software-defined networking (SDN) and OpenFlow. "Originating from the campus and data centre world, network programmability is increasingly seen as key for tighter integration, more automation, and virtualisation of IT and computing services," says Elbers.
The industry increasingly sees the metro market as important to ramp up 100Gbps volumes, with different modulation solutions being promoted by vendors. These include performance reduced 100Gbps DP-QPSK (dual polarisation, quadrature phase-shift keying), 200Gbps DP-16QAM (dual polarisation, 16-quadrature amplitude modulation) and 4x28G direct-detection.
While some people expressed concerns about a fragmentation of the 100 Gig market, power consumption, footprint and cost are of primary importance in the metro, he says. "One analyst at the Ovum 100Gbps metro workshop at OFC said: 'Maybe, for a hammer everything looks like a nail…'," says Elbers. "With 4x28G optical duobinary being able to make use of 10Gbps T-XFP/SFP+, IEEE 802.3ba and CFP technologies, we believe there is a justification to differentiate."
ADVA demonstrated its 4x28Gbps optical duobinary direct-detection product at the show.
Elbers noted an interest in multi-core and few-mode fibres. "The next x10 in bandwidth is difficult to reach as additional gains from amplification, modulation, FEC and denser carrier spacing will be limited." he says. "The research community therefore is looking into new fibre types to add the spatial and modal dimensions alongside the current optimisation strategy." An area interesting to watch, but fundamental technical and economic challenges remain, he says.
He too is optimistic about the industry's prospects: "Traffic and content keeps growing at exponential scale - the fundamental demand drivers are intact." As a result, optical innovation will play an even bigger role in the future to keep pace with the bandwidth growth, he says.
Karen Liu, Ovum
"We're clearly in a technology-pull phase rather than technology-push phase with multiple system vendors doing 400Gbps-capable stuff instead of component guys showing demonstrations years in advance of system activity," says Karen Liu, principal analyst, components telecoms at Ovum.
"Optical burst mode switching may be crossing over from rather 'pie-in-the-sky' to practical"
Karen Liu, Ovum
It is not that that the components vendors aren't making innovative products, she says, just that they are not making announcements until there is real demand. "Corning, for example, showed a fiber that has already been shipping into Lightpeak," says Liu.
What surprised Liu at the show was Huawei's optical burst transport network prototype. "Optical burst mode switching may be crossing over from rather 'pie-in-the-sky' to practical," says Liu.
She notes how there isn't as much optics-versus-electronics positioning anymore but more a case of optics working with electronics. "Huawei's OBTN is an example," says Liu. "Instead of using optical burst mode to make an all-optical network, optics is part of a hybrid design."
Liu says there are now multiple relationships between silicon and optics including the two working together instead of in competition. "In networking, the term translucent networks seems to have gained popularity."
Cisco Systems' 100 Gigabit spans metro to ultra long-haul
Cisco Systems has demonstrated 100 Gigabit transmission over a 3,000km span. The coherent-based system uses a single carrier in a 50GHz channel to transmit at 100 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps). According to Cisco, no Raman amplification or signal regeneration is needed to achieve the 3,000km reach.
Feature: Beyond 100G - Part 2
"The days of a single modulation scheme on a part are probably going to come to an end in the next two to three years"
Greg Nehib, Cisco
The 100Gbps design is also suited to metro networks. Cisco's design is compact to meet the more stringent price and power requirements of metro. The company says it can fit 42, 100Gbps transponders in its ONS 15454 Multi-service Transport Platform (MSTP), which is a 7-foot rack. "We think that is double the density of our nearest competitor today," claims Greg Nehib, product manager, marketing at Cisco Systems.
Also shown as part of the Cisco demonstration was the use of super-channels, multiple carriers that are combined to achieve 400 Gigabit or 1 Terabit signals.
Single-carrier 100 Gigabit
Several of the first-generation 100Gbps systems from equipment makers use two carriers (each carrying 50Gbps) in a 50GHz channel, and while such equipment requires lower-speed electronics, twice as many coherent transmitters and receivers are needed overall.
Alcatel-Lucent is one vendor that has a single-carrier 50GHz system and so has Huawei. Ciena via its Nortel acquisition offers a dual-carrier 100Gbps system, as does Infinera. With Ciena's announcement of its WaveLogic 3 chipset, it is now moving to a single-carrier solution. Now Cisco is entering the market with a single-carrier system.
"When you have a single carrier, you can get upwards of 96 channels of 100Gbps in the C-band," says Nehib. "The equation here is about price, performance, density and power."
What has been done
Cisco's 100Gbps design fits on a 1RU (rack unit) card and uses the first 100Gbps coherent receiver ASIC designed by the CoreOptics team acquired by Cisco in May 2010.
The demonstrated 3,000km reach was made using low-loss fibre. "This is to some degree a hero experiment," says Nehib. "We have achieved 3,000km with SMF ULL fibre from Corning; the LL is low loss." Normal fibre has a loss of 0.20-0.25dB/km while for ULL fibre it is in the 0.17dB/km range.
"You can do the maths and calculate the loss we are overcoming over 3,000km. We just want to signal that we have very good performance for ultra long-haul," says Nehib, who admits that results will vary in networks, depending on the fibre.
Nehib says Cisco's coherent receiver achieves a chromatic dispersion tolerance of 70,000 ps/nm and 100ps differential group delay. Differential group delay is a non-linear effect, says Nehib, that is overcome using the DSP-ASIC. The greater the group delay tolerance, the better the distance performance. These metrics, claims Cisco, are currently unmatched in the industry.
The company has not said what CMOS process it is using for its ASIC design. But this is not the main issue, says Nehib: "We are trying to develop a part that is small so that it fits in many different platforms, and we can now use a single part number to go from metro performance all the way to ultra long-haul."
Another factor that impacts span performance is the number of lit channels. Cisco, in the test performed by independent test lab EANTC, the European Advanced Network Test Center, used 70 wavelengths. "With 70 channels the performance would have been very close to what we would have achieved with [a full complement of] 80 channels," says Nehib.
Super-channels
A super-channel refers to a signal made up of several wavelengths. Infinera, with its DTN-X, uses a 500Gbps super-channel, comprising five 100Gbps wavelengths.
Using a super-channel, an operator can turn up multiple 100Gbps channels at once. If an operator wants to add a 100Gbps wavelength, a client interface is simply added to a spare 100Gbps wavelength making up the super-channel. In contrast turning up a 100Gbps wavelength in current systems usually requires several days of testing to ensure it can carry live traffic alongside existing links.
Another benefit of super-channels is scale by turning up multiple wavelengths simultaneously. As traffic grows so does the work load on operators' engineering teams. Super-channels aid efficiency.
"There is one other point that we hear quite often," says Nehib. "One other attraction of super-channels is overall spectral efficiency." The carriers that make up the signal can be packed more closely, expanding overall fibre capacity.
"Just like with 10 Gig, we think at some point in the future the 100 Gig network will be depleted, especially in the largest networks, and operators will be interested in 400 Gig and Terabit interfaces," says Nehib. "If that wavelength can further benefit from advanced modulation schemes and super-channels through flex[ible] spectrum deployment then you can get more total bandwidth on the fibre and better utilisation of your amplifiers."
Cisco's 100Gbps lab demonstration also showed 400 Gigabit and 1 Terabit super-channels, part of its research work with the Politechnico di Torino. "We are going to move on to other advanced modulation techniques and deliver 400 Gigabit and Terabit interfaces in future," says Nehib.
Existing 100Gbps systems use dual-polarisation, quadrature phase-shift keying (DP-QPSK). Using 16-QAM (quadrature amplitude modulation) at the same baud rate doubles the data rate. Using 16-QAM also benefits spectral utilisation. If the more intelligent modulation format is used in a super-channel format, and the signal is fitted in the most appropriate channel spacing using flexible spectrum ROADMs, overall capacity is increased. However, the spectral efficiency of 16-QAM comes at the expense of overall reach.
"You are able to best match the rate to the reach to the spectrum," says Nehib. "The days of a single modulation scheme on a part are probably going to come to an end in the next two to three years."
Cisco has yet to discuss the addition of a coherent transmitter DSP which through spectral shaping can bunch wavelengths. Such an approach has just been detailed by Ciena with its WaveLogic 3 and Alcatel-Lucent with its 400 Gig photonic service engine.
For the Terabit super-channel demonstration, Cisco used 16-QAM and a flexible spectrum multiplexer. "The demo that we showed is not necessarily indicative of the part we will bring to market," says Nehib, pointing out that it is still early in the development cycle. "We are looking at the spectral efficiency of super-channels, different modulation schemes, flex-spectrum multiplexer, availability, quality, loss etc.," says Nehib. "We have not made firm technology choices yet."
Cisco's 100Gbps system is in trials with some 40 customers and can be ordered now. The product will be generally available in the near future, it says.
Further reading:
Light Reading: EANTC's independent test of Cisco's CloudVerse architecture. Part 4: Long-haul optical transport
Ciena: Changing bandwidth on the fly
Ciena has announced its latest coherent chipset that will be the foundation for its future optical transmission offerings. The chipset, dubbed WaveLogic 3, will extend the performance of its 100 Gigabit links while introducing transmission flexibility that will trade capacity with reach.
Feature: Beyond 100 Gigabit - Part 1
"We are going to be deployed, [with WaveLogic 3] running live traffic in many customers’ networks by the end of the year"
Michael Adams, Ciena
"This is changing bandwidth modulation on the fly," says Ron Kline, principal analyst, network infrastructure group at market research firm, Ovum. “The capability will allow users to dynamically optimise wavelengths to match application performance requirements.”
WaveLogic 3 is Ciena's third-generation coherent chipset that introduces several firsts for the company.
- The chipset supports single-carrier 100 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) transmission in a 50GHz channel.
- The chipset includes a transmit digital signal processor (DSP) - which can adapt the modulation schemes as well as shape the pulses to increase spectral efficiency. The coherent transmitter DSP is the first announced in the industry.
- WaveLogic 3's second chip, the coherent receiver DSP, also includes soft-decision forward error correction (SD-FEC). SD-FEC is important for high-capacity metro and regional, not just long-haul and trans-Pacific routes, says Ciena.
The two-ASIC chipset is implemented using a 32nm CMOS process. According to Ciena, the receiver DSP chip, which compensates for channel impairments, measures 18 mm sq. and is capable of 75 Tera-operations a second.
Ciena says the chipset supports three modulation formats: dual-polarisation bipolar phase-shift keying (DP-BPSK), quadrature phase-shift keying (DP-QPSK) and 16-QAM (quadrature amplitude modulation). Using a single carrier, these equate to 50Gbps, 100Gbps and 200Gbps data rates. Going to 16-QAM may increase the data rate to 200Gbps but it comes at a cost: a loss in spectral efficiency and in reach.
"This software programmability is critical for today's dynamic, cloud-centric networks," says Michael Adams, Ciena’s vice president of product & technology marketing.
WaveLogic 3 has also been designed to scale to 400Gbps. "This is the first programmable coherent technology scalable to 400 Gig," says Adams. "For 400 Gig, we would be using a dual-carrier, dual-polarisation 16-QAM that would use multiple [WaveLogic 3] chipsets."
Performance
Ciena stresses that this is a technology not a product announcement. But it is willing to detail that in a terrestrial network, a single carrier 100Gbps link using WaveLogic 3 can achieve a reach of 2,500+ km. "These refer to a full-fill [wavelengths in the C-Band] and average fibre," says Adams. "This is not a hero test with one wavelength and special [low-loss] fibre.”
Metro to trans-Pacific: The different reaches and distances over terrestrial and submarine using Ciena's WaveLogic 3. SC stands for single carrier. Source: Ciena/ Gazettabyte
When the modulation is changed to BPSK, the reach is effectively doubled. And Ciena expects a 9,000-10,000km reach on submarine links.
The same single-carrier 50GHz channel reverting to 16-QAM can transmit a 200Gbps signal over distances of 750-1,000km. "A modulation change [to 16-QAM] and adding a second 100 Gigabit Ethernet transceiver and immediately you get an economic improvement," says Adams.
For 400Gbps, two carriers, each 16-QAM, are needed and the distances achieved are 'metro regional', says Ciena.
The transmit DSP also can implement spectral shaping. According to Ciena, by shaping the signals sent, a 20-30% bandwidth improvement (capacity increase) can be achieved. However that feature will only be fully exploited once networks deploy flexible grid ROADMs.
At OFC/NFOEC. Ciena will be showing a prototype card that will demonstrate the modulation going from BPSK to QPSK to 16-QAM. "We are going to be deployed, running live traffic in many customers’ networks by the end of the year," says Adams.
Analysis
Sterling Perrin, senior analyst, Heavy Reading
Heavy Reading believes Ciena's WaveLogic 3 is an impressive development, compared to its current WaveLogic 2 and to other available coherent chipsets. But Perrin thinks the most significant WaveLogic 3 development is Ciena’s single-carrier 100Gbps debut.
Until now, Ciena has used two carriers within a 50GHz, each carrying 50Gbps of data.
"The dual carrier approach gave Ciena a first-to-market advantage at 100Gbps, but we have seen the vendor lose ground as Alcatel-Lucent rolled out its single carrier 100Gbps system," says Perrin in a Heavy Reading research note. "We believe that Alcatel-Lucent was the market leader in 100Gbps transport in 2011."
Other suppliers, including Cisco Systems and Huawei, have also announced single-carrier 100Gbps, and more single-wavelength 100Gbps announcements will come throughout 2012.
Heavy Reading believes the ability to scale to 400Gbps is important, as is the use of multiple carriers (or super-channels). But 400 Gigabit and 1 Terabit transport are still years away and 100Gbps transport will be the core networking technology for a long time yet.
"The vendors with the best 100G systems will be best-positioned to capture share over the next five years, we believe," says Perrin.
Ron Kline, principal analyst for Ovum’s network infrastructure group.
For Ron Kline, Ciena's announcement was less of a surprise. Ciena showcased WaveLogic 3's to analysts late last year. The challenge with such a technology announcement is understanding the capabilities and how it will be rolled out and used within a product, he says.
"Ciena's WaveLogic 3 is the basis for 400 Gig," says Kline. "They are not out there saying 'we have 400 Gig'." Instead, what the company is stressing is the degree of added capacity, intelligence and flexibility that WaveLogic 3 will deliver. That said, Ciena does have trials planned for 400 Gig this year, he says.
What is noteworthy, says Ovum, is that 400Gbps is within Ciena's grasp whereas there are still some vendors yet to record revenues for 100Gbps.
"Product differentiation has changed - it used to be about coherent," says Kline. "But now that nearly all vendors have coherent, differentiation is going to be determined by who has the best coherent technology."
Infinera details Terabit PICs, 5x100G devices set for 2012
Infinera has given first detail of its terabit coherent detection photonic integrated circuits (PICs). The pair - a transmitter and a receiver PIC – implement a ten-channel 100 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) link using polarisation multiplexing quadrature phase-shift keying (PM-QPSK). The Infinera development work was detailed at OFC/NFOEC held in Los Angeles between March 6-10.
Infinera has recently demonstrated its 5x100Gbps PIC carrying traffic between Amsterdam and London within Interoute Communications’ pan-European network. The 5x100Gbps PIC-based system will be available commercially in 2012.
“We think we can drive the system from where it is today – 8 Terabits-per-fibre - to around 25 Terabits-per-fibre”
Dave Welch, Infinera
Why is this significant?
The widespread adoption of 100Gbps optical transport technology will be driven by how quickly its cost can be reduced to compete with existing 40Gbps and 10Gbps technologies.
Whereas the industry is developing 100Gbps line cards and optical modules, Infinera has demonstrated a 5x100Gbps coherent PIC based on 50GHz channel spacing while its terabit PICs are in the lab.
If Infinera meets its manufacturing plans, it will have a compelling 100Gbps offering as it takes on established 100Gbps players such as Ciena. Infinera has been late in the 40Gbps market, competing with its 10x10Gbps PIC technology instead.
40 and 100 Gigabit
Infinera views 40Gbps and 100Gbps optical transport in terms of the dynamics of the high-capacity fibre market. In particular what is the right technology to get most capacity out of a fibre and what is the best dollar-per-Gigabit technology at a given moment.
For the long-haul market, Dave Welch, chief strategy officer at Infinera, says 100Gbps provides 8 Terabits (Tb) of capacity using 80 channels versus 3.2Tb using 40Gbps (80x40Gbps). The 40Gbps total capacity can be doubled to 6.4Tb (160x40Gbps) if 25GHz-spaced channels are used, which is Infinera’s approach.
“The economics of 100 Gigabit appear to be able to drive the dollar-per-gigabit down faster than 40 Gigabit technology,” says Welch. If operators need additional capacity now, they will adopt 40Gbps, he says, but if they have spare capacity and can wait till 2012 they can use 100Gbps. “The belief is that they [operators] will get more capacity out of their fibre and at least the same if not better economics per gigabit [using 100Gbps],” says Welch. Indeed Welch argues that by 2012, 100Gbps economics will be superior to 40Gbps coherent leading to its “rapid adoption”.
For metro applications, achieving terabits of capacity in fibre is less of a concern. What matters is matching speeds with services while achieving the lowest dollar-per-gigabit. And it is here – for sub-1000km networks – where 40Gbps technology is being mostly deployed. “Not for the benefit of maximum fibre capacity but to protect against service interfaces,” says Welch, who adds that 40 Gigabit Ethernet (GbE) rather than 100GbE is the preferred interface within data centres.
Shorter-reach 100Gbps
Companies such as ADVA Optical Networking and chip company MultiPhy highlight the merits of an additional 100Gbps technology to coherent based on direct detection modulation for metro applications (for a MultiPhy webinar on 100Gbps direct detection, click here). Direct detection is suited to distances from 80km up to 1000km, to connect data centres for example.
Is this market of interest to Infinera? “This is a great opportunity for us,” says Welch.
The company’s existing 10x10Gbps PIC can address this segment in that it is least 4x cheaper than emerging 100Gbps coherent solutions over the next 18 months, says Welch, who claims that the company’s 10x10Gbps PIC is making ‘great headway’ in the metro.
“If the market is not trying to get the maximum capacity but best dollar-per-gigabit, it is not clear that full coherent, at least in discrete form, is the right answer,” says Welch. But the cost reduction delivered by coherent PIC technology does makes it more competitive for cost-sensitive markets like metro.
A 100Gbps coherent discrete design is relatively costly since it requires two lasers (one as a local oscillator (LO - see fig 1 - at the receiver), sophisticated optics and a high power-consuming digital signal processor (DSP). “Once you go to photonic integration the extra lasers and extra optics, while a significant engineering task, are not inhibitors in terms of the optics’ cost.”
Coherent PICs can be used ‘deeper in the network’ (closer to the edge) while shifting the trade-offs between coherent and on-off keying. However even if the advent of a PIC makes coherent more economical, the DSP’s power dissipation remains a factor regarding the tradeoff at 100Gbps line rates between on-off keying and coherent.
Welch does not dismiss the idea of Infinera developing a metro-centric PIC to reduce costs further. He points out that while such a solution may be of particular interest to internet content companies, their networks are relatively simple point-to-point ones. As such their needs differ greatly from cable operators and telcos, in terms of the services carried and traffic routing.
PIC challenges
Figure 1: Infinera's terabit PM-QPSK coherent receiver PIC architecture
There are several challenges when developing multi-channel 100Gbps PICs. “The most difficult thing going to a coherent technology is you are now dealing with optical phase,” says Welch. This requires highly accurate control of the PIC’s optical path lengths.
The laser wavelength is 1.5 micron and with the PIC's indium phosphide waveguides this is reduced by a third to 0.5 micron. Fine control of the optical path lengths is thus required to tenths of a wavelength or tens of nanometers (nm).
Achieving a high manufacturing yield of such complex PICs is another challenge. The terabit receiver PIC detailed in the OFC paper integrates 150 optical components, while the 5x100Gbps transmit and receive PIC pair integrate the equivalent of 600 optical components.
Moving from a five-channel (500Gbps) to a ten-channel (terabit) PIC is also a challenge. There are unwanted interactions in terms of the optics and the electronics. “If I turn one laser on adjacent to another laser it has a distortion, while the light going through the waveguides has potential for polarisation scattering,” says Welch. “It is very hard.”
But what the PICs shows, he says, is that Infinera’s manufacturing process is like a silicon fab’s. “We know what is predictable and the [engineering] guys can design to that,” says Welch. “Once you have got that design capability, you can envision we are going to do 500Gbps, a terabit, two terabits, four terabits – you can keep on marching as far as the gigabits-per-unit [device] can be accomplished by this technology.”
The OFC post-deadline paper details Infinera's 10-channel transmitter PIC which operates at 10x112Gbps or 1.12Tbps.
Power dissipation
The optical PIC is not what dictates overall bandwidth achievable but rather the total power dissipation of the DSPs on a line card. This is determined by the CMOS process used to make the DSP ASICs, whether 65nm, 40nm or potentially 28nm.
Infinera has not said what CMOS process it is using. What Infinera has chosen is a compromise between “being aggressive in the industry and what is achievable”, says Welch. Yet Infinera also claims that its coherent solution consumes less power than existing 100Gbps coherent designs, partly because the company has implemented the DSP in a more advanced CMOS node than what is currently being deployed. This suggests that Infinera is using a 40nm process for its coherent receiver ASICs. And power consumption is a key reason why Infinera is entering the market with a 5x100Gbps PIC line card. For the terabit PIC, Infinera will need to move its ASICs to the next-generation process node, he says.
Having an integrated design saves power in terms of the speeds that Infinera runs its serdes (serialiser/ deserialiser) circuitry and the interfaces between blocks. “For someone else to accumulate 500Gbps of bandwdith and get it to a switch, this needs to go over feet of copper cable, and over a backplane when one 100Gbps line card talks to a second one,” says Welch. “That takes power - we don’t; it is all right there within inches of each other.”
Infinera can also trade analogue-to-digital (A/D) sampling speed of its ASIC with wavelength count depending on the capacity required. “Now you have a PIC with a bank of lasers, and FlexCoherent allows me to turn a knob in software so I can go up in spectral efficiency,” he says, trading optical reach with capacity. FlexCoherent is Infinera’s technology that will allow operators to choose what coherent optical modulation format to use on particular routes. The modulation formats supported are polarisation multiplexed binary phase-shift keying (PM-BPSK) and PM-QPSK.
Dual polarisation 25Gbaud constellation diagrams
What next?
Infinera says it is an adherent of higher quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) rates to increase the data rate per channel beyond 100Gbps. As a result FlexCoherent in future will enable the selection of higher-speed modulation schemes such as 8-QAM and 16-QAM. “We think we can drive the system from where it is today –8 Terabits-per-fibre - to around 25 Terabits-per-fiber.”
But Welch stresses that at 16-QAM and even higher level speeds must be traded with optical reach. Fibre is different to radio, he says. Whereas radio uses higher QAM rates, it compensates by increasing the launch power. In contrast there is a limit with fibre. “The nonlinearity of the fibre inhibits higher and higher optical power,” says Welch. “The network will have to figure out how to accommodate that, although there is still significant value in getting to that [25Tbps per fibre]” he says.
The company has said that its 500 Gigabit PIC will move to volume manufacturing in 2012. Infinera is also validating the system platform that will use the PIC and has said that it has a five terabit switching capacity.
Infinera is also offering a 40Gbps coherent (non-PIC-based) design this year. “We are working with third-party support to make a module that will have unique performance for Infinera,” says Welch.
The next challenge is getting the terabit PIC onto the line card. Based on the gap between previous OFC papers to volume manufacturing, the 10x100Gbps PIC can be expected in volume by 2014 if all goes to plan.