BT makes plans for continued traffic growth in its core
Part 1
Kevin Smith: “A lot of the work we are doing with the trials have demonstrated we can scale our networks gracefully rather than there being a brick wall of a problem.”
BT is confident that its core network will accommodate the expected IP traffic growth for the next decade. Traffic in BT’s core is growing at between 35 and 40 percent annually, compared to the global average growth rate of 20 to 30 percent. BT attributes the higher growth to the rollout of fibre-based broadband across the UK.
The telco is deploying 100-gigabit wavelengths in high-traffic areas of its network. “These are key sites where we're running out of wavelengths such that we need to implement higher-speed ones,” says Kevin Smith, research leader for BT’s transport networks. The operator is now trialling 200-gigabit wavelengths using polarisation multiplexing, 16-quadrature amplitude modulation (PM-16QAM).
Adopting higher-order modulation increases capacity and spectral efficiency but at the expense of a loss in system performance which can be significant.
Systems vendors use polarisation-multiplexed, quadrature phase-shift keying (PM-QPSK) for 100-gigabit wavelengths. Moving to PM-16QAM doubles the bits on the wavelength but the received data has less tolerance to noise. The result is a 6-decibel loss compared to PM-QPSK, such that the transmission distance drops to a quarter. If PM-QPSK spans a 4,000km link, using PM-16QAM the reach on the same link is only 1,000km.
The transmitted capacity can also be increased by using pulse-shaping at the transmitter to cram a wavelength into a narrower channel. BT’s existing optical network uses fixed 50GHz-wide channels. But in a recent network trial with Huawei, a 3 terabit super-channel was transmitted over a 360km link using a flexible grid.
The super-channel comprised 15 channels, each carrying 200 gigabit using PM-16QAM. Using the flexible grid, each carrier occupied a 33.5GHz channel, increasing fibre capacity by a factor of 1.5 compared to a 50GHz fixed-grid. “For 16-QAM, it [33.5GHz] is pretty close to the limit,” says Smith.
Increasing the baud rate is the most structurally-efficient way to accommodate the high speed
Another way to boost the carrier’s data as well as reduce system cost is to up the signalling rate. Current optical transport systems use a 30Gbaud symbol rate. Here, two carriers each using PM-16QAM are needed to deliver 400 gigabit. Doubling the symbol rate to 60Gbaud enables a single 400 gigabit wavelength. Doubling the baud rate also halves a platform’s transponder count, reducing the overall cost-per-bit, and increases platform density.
“Increasing the baud rate is the most structurally-efficient way to accommodate the high speed,” says Smith. Going to 16QAM increases the data that is carried but at the expense of reach. By increasing the baud rate, reach can be extended while also keeping the modulation rate at a lower level, he says.
BT says it is seeing signs of such ‘flexrate’ transponders that can adapt modulation format and baud rate. “This is a very interesting area we can mine,” says Smith. The fundamental driver is about reducing cost but also giving BT more flexibility in its network, he says.
Traffic growth
Coping with traffic growth is a constant challenge, says BT.
“I’m not worried about a capacity crunch,” says Smith. “A lot of the work we are doing with the trials have demonstrated we can scale our networks gracefully rather than there being a brick wall of a problem.”
The operator is confident that 25 to 30 terabit of traffic can be squeezed into the C-band using flexgrid and narrower bands. Beyond that, BT says broadening the spectral window using additional spectral bands such as the L-band could boost a fibre’s capacity to 100 terabit. Vendors are already looking at extending the spectral window, says BT.
Sliceable transponders
BT is also part of longer-term research exploring an extension to the ‘flexrate' transponder, dubbed the sliceable bit rate variable transponder (S-BVT).
“It is very much early days but the idea is to put multiple modulators on the same big super transponder so that it can kick out super-channels that can be provisioned on demand,” says Andrew Lord, head of optical research at BT.
The large multi-terabit super-channel would be sent out and sliced further down the network by flexible grid wavelength-selective switches such that parts of the super-channel would end up at different destinations. “You don’t need all that capacity to go to one other node but you might need it to go to multiple nodes,” says Lord.
Such a sliceable transponder promises several benefits. One is an ability to keep repartitioning the multi-terabit slice based on demand. “It is a good thing if we see that kind of dynamics happening, but not fast dynamics,” says Lord. The repartitioning would more likely be occasional, adding extra capacity between nodes based on demand. Accordingly, the sliced multi-terabit super-channel would end up at fewer destinations over time.
The sliceable transponder concept also promises cost reduction through greater component integration.
BT stresses this is still early research but such a transponder could end up in the network in five years’ time.
Space-division multiplexing
Another research area that promises to increase significantly the overall capacity of a fibre is space-division multiplexing (SDM).
SDM promises to boost the capacity by a factor of between 10 and 100 through the adoption of parallel transmission paths. The simplest way to create such parallel paths is to bundle several standard single-mode fibres in a cable. But speciality fibre could also be used, either multi-core or multi-mode.
BT says it is not researching spatial multiplexing.
”I’m very much more interested in how we use the fibre we have already got,” says Lord. The priority is pushing channels together as close as possible and getting the 25 terabit figure higher, as well as exploring the L-band. “That is a much more practical way to go forward,” says Lord.
However, BT welcomes the research into SDM. “What it [SDM] is pushing into the industry is a knowledge about how to do integration and the expertise that comes out of that is still really valid,” says Lord. “As it is, I don’t see how it fits.”
ECOC reflections: final part
Gazettabyte asked several attendees at the recent ECOC show, held in Cannes, to comment on key developments and trends they noted, as well as the issues they will track in the coming year.
Dr. Ioannis Tomkos, Fellow of OSA & Fellow of IET, Athens Information Technology Center (AIT)
With ECOC 2014 celebrating its 40th anniversary, the technical programme committee did its best to mark the occasion. For example, at the anniversary symposium, notable speakers presented the history of optical communications. Actual breakthroughs discussed during the conference sessions were limited, however.
Ioannis Tomkos
It appears that after 2008 to 2012, a period of significant advancements, the industry is now more mainstream, and significant shifts in technologies are limited. It is clear that the original focus four decades ago on novel photonics technologies is long gone. Instead, there is more and more of a focus on high-speed electronics, signal processing algorithms, and networking. These have little to do with photonics even if they greatly improve the overall efficient operation of optical communication systems and networks.
Coherent detection technology is making its way in metro with commercial offerings becoming available, while in academia it is also discussed as a possible solution for future access network applications where long-reach, very-high power budgets and high-bit rates per customer are required. However, this will only happen if someone can come up with cost-effective implementations.
Advanced modulation formats and the associated digital signal processing are now well established for ultra-high capacity spectral-efficient transmission. The focus in now on forward-error-correction codes and their efficient implementations to deliver the required differentiation and competitive advantage of one offering versus another. This explains why so many of the relevant sessions and talks were so well attended.
There were several dedicated sessions covering flexible/ elastic optical networking. It was also mentioned in the plenary session by operator Orange. It looks like a field that started only fives years ago is maturing and people are now convinced about the significant short-term commercial potential of related solutions. Regarding latest research efforts in this field, people have realised that flexible networking using spectral super-channels will offer the most benefit if it becomes possible to access the contents of the super-channels at intermediate network locations/ nodes. To achieve that, besides traditional traffic grooming approaches such as those based on OTN, there were also several ground-breaking presentations proposing all-optical techniques to add/ drop sub-channels out of the super-channel.
Progress made so far on long-haul high-capacity space-division-multiplexed systems, as reported in a tutorial, invited talks and some contributed presentations, is amazing, yet the potential for wide-scale deployment of such technology was discussed by many as being at least a decade away. Certainly, this research generates a lot of interesting know-how but the impact in the industry might come with a long delay, after flexible networking and terabit transmission becomes mainstream.
Much attention was also given at ECOC to the application of optical communications in data centre networks, from data-centre interconnection to chip-to-chip links. There were many dedicated sessions and all were well attended.
Besides short-term work on high-bit-rate transceivers, there is also much effort towards novel silicon photonic integration approaches for realising optical interconnects, space-division-multiplexing approaches that for sure will first find their way in data centres, and even efforts related with the application of optical switching in data centres.
At the networking sessions, the buzz was around software-defined networking (SDN) and network functions virtualisation (NFV) now at the top of the “hype-cycle”. Both technologies have great potential to disrupt the industry structure, but scientific breakthroughs are obviously limited.
As for my interests going forward, I intend to look for more developments in the field of mobile traffic front-haul/ back-haul for the emerging 5G networks, as well as optical networking solutions for data centres since I feel that both markets present significant growth opportunities for the optical communications/ networking industry and the ECOC scientific community.
Dr. Jörg-Peter Elbers, vice president advanced technology, CTO Office, ADVA Optical Networking
The top topics at ECOC 2014 for me were elastic networks covering flexible grid, super-channels and selectable higher-order modulation; transport SDN; 100-Gigabit-plus data centre interconnects; mobile back- and front-hauling; and next-generation access networks.
For elastic networks, an optical layer with a flexible wavelength grid has become the de-facto standard. Investigations on the transceiver side are not just focussed on increasing the spectral efficiency, but also at increasing the symbol rate as a prospect for lowering the number of carriers for 400-Gigabit-plus super-channels and cost while maintaining the reach.
Jörg-Peter Elbers
As we approach the Shannon limit, spectral efficiency gains are becoming limited. More papers were focussed on multi-core and/or few-mode fibres as a way to increase fibre capacity.
Transport SDN work is focussing on multi-tenancy network operation and multi-layer/ multi-domain network optimisation as the main use cases. Due to a lack of a standard for north-bound interfaces and a commonly agreed information model, many published papers are relying on vendor-specific implementations and proprietary protocol extensions.
Direct detect technologies for 400 Gigabit data centre interconnects are a hot topic in the IEEE and the industry. Consequently, there were a multitude of presentations, discussions and demonstrations on this topic with non-return-to-zero (NRZ), pulse amplitude modulation (PAM) and discrete multi-tone (DMT) being considered as the main modulation options. 100 Gigabit per wavelength is a desirable target for 400 Gig interconnects, to limit the overall number of parallel wavelengths. The obtainable optical performance on long links, specifically between geographically-dispersed data centres, though, may require staying at 50 Gig wavelengths.
In mobile back- and front-hauling, people increasingly recognise the timing challenges associated with LTE-Advanced networks and are looking for WDM-based networks as solutions. In the next-generation access space, components and solutions around NG-PON2 and its evolution gained most interest. Low-cost tunable lasers are a prerequisite and several companies are working on such solutions with some of them presenting results at the conference.
Questions around the use of SDN and NFV in optical networks beyond transport SDN point to the access and aggregation networks as a primary application area. The capability to programme the forwarding behaviour of the networks, and place and chain software network functions where they best fit, is seen as a way of lowering operational costs, increasing network efficiency and providing service agility and elasticity.
What did I learn at the show/ conference? There is a lot of development in optical components, leading to innovation cycles not always compatible with those of routers and switches. In turn, the cost, density and power consumption of short-reach interconnects is continually improving and these performance metrics are all lower than what can be achieved with line interfaces. This raises the question whether separating the photonic layer equipment from the electronic switching and routing equipment is not a better approach than building integrated multi-layer god-boxes.
There were no notable new trends or surprises at ECOC this year. Most of the presented work continued and elaborated on topics already identified.
As for what we will track closely in the coming year, all of the above developments are of interesting. Inter-data centre connectivity, WDM-PON and open programmable optical core networks are three to mention in particular.
For the first ECOC reflections, click here
Space-division multiplexing: the final frontier
System vendors continue to trumpet their achievements in long-haul optical transmission speeds and overall data carried over fibre.
Alcatel-Lucent announced earlier this month that France Telecom-Orange is using the industry's first 400 Gigabit link, connecting Paris and Lyon, while Infinera has detailed a trial demonstrating 8 Terabit-per-second (Tbps) of capacity over 1,175km and using 500 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) super-channels.
"Integration always comes at the cost of crosstalk"
Peter Winzer, Bell Labs
Yet vendors already recognise that capacity in the frequency domain will only scale so far and that other approaches are required. One is space-division multiplexing such as using multiple channels separated in space and implemented using multi-core fibre with each core supporting several modes.
"We want a technology that scales by a factor of 10 to 100," says Peter Winzer, director of optical transmission systems and networks research at Bell Labs. "As an example, a fibre with 10 cores with each core supporting 10 modes, then you have the factor of 100."
Space-division multiplexing
Alcatel-Lucent's research arm, Bell Labs, has demonstrated the transmission of 3.8Tbps using several data channels and an advanced signal processing technique known as multiple-input, multiple-output (MIMO).
In particular, 40 Gigabit quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK) signals were sent over a six-spatial mode fibre using two polarisation modes and eight wavelengths to achieve 3.8Tbps. The overall transmission uses 400GHz of spectrum only.
Alcatel-Lucent stresses that the commercial deployment of space-division multiplexing remains years off. Moreover operators will likely first use already-deployed parallel strands of single-mode fibre, needing the advanced signal processing techniques only later.
"You might say that is trivial [using parallel strands of fibre], but bringing down the cost of that solution is not," says Winzer.
First, cost-effective integrated amplifiers will be needed. "We need to work on a single amplifier that can amplify, say, ten existing strands of single-mode fibre at the cost of two single-mode amplifiers," says Winzer. An integrated transponder will also be needed: one transponder that couples to 10 individual fibres at a much lower cost than 10 individual transponders.
With a super-channel transponder, several wavelengths are used, each with its own laser, modulator and detector. "In a spatial super-channel you have the same thing, but not, say, three different frequencies but three different spatial paths," says Winzer. Here photonic integration is the challenge to achieve a cost-effective transponder.
Once such integrated transponders and amplifiers become available, it will make sense to couple them to multi-core fibre. But operators will only likely start deploying new fibre once they exhaust their parallel strands of single-mode fibre.
Such integrated amplifiers and integrated transponders will present challenges. "The more and more you integrate, the more and more crosstalk you will have," says Winzer. "That is fundamental: integration always comes at the cost of crosstalk."
Winzer says there are several areas where crosstalk may arise. An integrated amplifier serving ten single-mode fibres will share a multi-core erbium-doped fibre instead of ten individual strands. Crosstalk between those closely-spaced cores is likely.
The transponder will be based on a large integrated circuit giving rise to electrical crosstalk. One way to tackle crosstalk is to develop components to a higher specification but that is more costly. Alternatively, signal processing on the received signal can be used to undo the crosstalk. Using electronics to counter crosstalk is attractive especially when it is the optics that dominate the design cost. This is where MIMO signal processing plays a role. "MIMO is the most advanced version of spatial multiplexing," says Winzer.
To address crosstalk caused by spatial multiplexing in the Bell Labs' demo, 12x12 MIMO was used. Bell Labs says that using MIMO does not add significantly to the overall computation. Existing 100 Gigabit coherent ASICs effectively use a 2x2 MIMO scheme, says Winzer: “We are extending the 2x2 MIMO to 2Nx2N MIMO.”
Only one portion of the current signal processing chain is impacted, he adds; a portion that consumes 10 percent of the power will need to increase by a certain factor. The resulting design will be more complex and expensive but not dramatically so, he says.
Winzer says such mitigation techniques need to be investigated now since crosstalk in future systems is inevitable. Even if the technology's deployment is at least a decade away, developing techniques to tackle crosstalk now means vendors have a clear path forward.
Parallelism
Winzer points out that optical transmission continues to embrace parallelism. "With super-channels we go parallel with multiple carriers because a single carrier can’t handle the traffic anymore," he says. This is similar to parallelism in microprocessors where multi-core designs are now used due to the diminishing return in continually increasing a single core's clock speed.
For 400Gbps or 1 Terabit over a single-mode fibre, the super-channel approach is the near term evolution.
Over the next decade, the benefit of frequency parallelism will diminish since it will no longer increase spectral efficiency. "Then you need to resort to another physical dimension for parallelism and that would be space," says Winzer.
MIMO will be needed when crosstalk arises and that will occur with multiple mode fibre.
"For multiple strands of single mode fibre it will depend on how much crosstalk the integrated optical amplifiers and transponders introduce," says Winzer.
Part 1: Terabit optical transmission