Space-division multiplexing: the final frontier

System vendors continue to trumpet their achievements in long-haul optical transmission speeds and overall data carried over fibre. 

Alcatel-Lucent announced earlier this month that France Telecom-Orange is using the industry's first 400 Gigabit link, connecting Paris and Lyon, while Infinera has detailed a trial demonstrating 8 Terabit-per-second (Tbps) of capacity over 1,175km and using 500 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps) super-channels. 

 

"Integration always comes at the cost of crosstalk"

Peter Winzer, Bell Labs

 

 

 

 

 

 

Yet vendors already recognise that capacity in the frequency domain will only scale so far and that other approaches are required. One is space-division multiplexing such as using multiple channels separated in space and implemented using multi-core fibre with each core supporting several modes.

 "We want a technology that scales by a factor of 10 to 100," says Peter Winzer, director of optical transmission systems and networks research at Bell Labs. "As an example, a fibre with 10 cores with each core supporting 10 modes, then you have the factor of 100."

 

Space-division multiplexing

Alcatel-Lucent's research arm, Bell Labs, has demonstrated the transmission of 3.8Tbps using several data channels and an advanced signal processing technique known as multiple-input, multiple-output (MIMO).

In particular, 40 Gigabit quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK) signals were sent over a six-spatial mode fibre using two polarisation modes and eight wavelengths to achieve 3.8Tbps. The overall transmission uses 400GHz of spectrum only.

Alcatel-Lucent stresses that the commercial deployment of space-division multiplexing remains years off. Moreover operators will likely first use already-deployed parallel strands of single-mode fibre, needing the advanced signal processing techniques only later.

"You might say that is trivial [using parallel strands of fibre], but bringing down the cost of that solution is not," says Winzer.

First, cost-effective integrated amplifiers will be needed. "We need to work on a single amplifier that can amplify, say, ten existing strands of single-mode fibre at the cost of two single-mode amplifiers," says Winzer. An integrated transponder will also be needed: one transponder that couples to 10 individual fibres at a much lower cost than 10 individual transponders.

With a super-channel transponder, several wavelengths are used, each with its own laser, modulator and detector. "In a spatial super-channel you have the same thing, but not, say, three different frequencies but three different spatial paths," says Winzer. Here photonic integration is the challenge to achieve a cost-effective transponder.

Once such integrated transponders and amplifiers become available, it will make sense to couple them to multi-core fibre. But operators will only likely start deploying new fibre once they exhaust their parallel strands of single-mode fibre.

Such integrated amplifiers and integrated transponders will present challenges. "The more and more you integrate, the more and more crosstalk you will have," says Winzer. "That is fundamental: integration always comes at the cost of crosstalk."

Winzer says there are several areas where crosstalk may arise. An integrated amplifier serving ten single-mode fibres will share a multi-core erbium-doped fibre instead of ten individual strands. Crosstalk between those closely-spaced cores is likely.

The transponder will be based on a large integrated circuit giving rise to electrical crosstalk. One way to tackle crosstalk is to develop components to a higher specification but that is more costly. Alternatively, signal processing on the received signal can be used to undo the crosstalk. Using electronics to counter crosstalk is attractive especially when it is the optics that dominate the design cost.  This is where MIMO signal processing plays a role. "MIMO is the most advanced version of spatial multiplexing," says Winzer.

To address crosstalk caused by spatial multiplexing in the Bell Labs' demo, 12x12 MIMO was used. Bell Labs says that using MIMO does not add significantly to the overall computation. Existing 100 Gigabit coherent ASICs effectively use a 2x2 MIMO scheme, says Winzer: “We are extending the 2x2 MIMO to 2Nx2N MIMO.” 

Only one portion of the current signal processing chain is impacted, he adds; a portion that consumes 10 percent of the power will need to increase by a certain factor. The resulting design will be more complex and expensive but not dramatically so, he says.

Winzer says such mitigation techniques need to be investigated now since crosstalk in future systems is inevitable. Even if the technology's deployment is at least a decade away, developing techniques to tackle crosstalk now means vendors have a clear path forward.

 

Parallelism

Winzer points out that optical transmission continues to embrace parallelism. "With super-channels we go parallel with multiple carriers because a single carrier can’t handle the traffic anymore," he says. This is similar to parallelism in microprocessors where multi-core designs are now used due to the diminishing return in continually increasing a single core's clock speed.

For 400Gbps or 1 Terabit over a single-mode fibre, the super-channel approach is the near term evolution.

Over the next decade, the benefit of frequency parallelism will diminish since it will no longer increase spectral efficiency. "Then you need to resort to another physical dimension for parallelism and that would be space," says Winzer.

MIMO will be needed when crosstalk arises and that will occur with multiple mode fibre.

"For multiple strands of single mode fibre it will depend on how much crosstalk the integrated optical amplifiers and transponders introduce," says Winzer.

 

Part 1: Terabit optical transmission


The evolution of optical networking

An upcoming issue of the Proceeedings of the IEEE will be dedicated solely to the topic of optical networking. This, says the lead editor, Professor Ioannis Tomkos at the Athens Information Technology Center, is a first in the journal's 100-year history.  The issue, entitled The Evolution of Optical Networking, will be published in either April or May and will have a dozen invited papers. 

 

One topic that will change the way we think about optical networks is flexible or elastic optical networks.

Professor Ioannis Tomkos

 

"If I have to pick one topic that will change the way we think about optical networks, it is flexible or elastic optical networks, and the associated technologies," says Tomkos.

A conventional dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM) network has fixed wavelengths. For long-haul optical transmission each wavelength has a fixed bit rate - 10, 40 or 100 Gigabit-per-second (Gbps), a fixed modulation format, and typically occupies a 50GHz channel.  "Such a network is very rigid," says Tomkos. "It cannot respond easily to changes in the network's traffic patterns." 

This arrangement has come about, says Tomkos, because the assumption has always been that fibre bandwidth is abundant. "But at the moment we are only a factor of two away from reaching the Shannon limit [in terms of spectral efficiency bits/s/Hz) so we are going to hit the fibre capacity wall by 2018-2020," he warns. 

The maximum theoretically predicted spectral efficiency for an optical communication system based on standard single-mode fibres is about 9bits/s/Hz per polarisation for typical long-haul system reaches of 500km without regeneration, says Tomkos. "At the moment the most advanced hero experiments demonstrated in labs have achieved a spectral efficiency of about 4-6bits/s/Hz," he says. This equates to a total transmission capacity close to 100 Terabits-per-second (Tbps).  After that, deploying more fibre will be the only way to further scale networks.

Accordingly, new thinking is required.

Two approaches are being proposed. One is to treat the optical network in the same way as the air interface in cellular networks: spectrum is scarce and must be used effectively.

"We are running close to fundamental limits, that's why the optical spectrum of available deployed standard single mode fibers should be utilized more efficiently from now on as is the case with wireless spectrum," says Tomkos.

 

How optical communication is following in the footsteps of wireless.

The second technique - spatial multiplexing - looks to extend fibre capacity well beyond what can be achieved using the first approach alone.  Such an option would need to deploy new fibre types that support multiple cores or multi-mode transmission.

 

Flexible spectrum 

"We have to start thinking about techniques used in wireless networks to be adopted in optical networks," says Tomkos (See text box).  With a flexible network, the thinking is to move from the 50GHz fixed grid, down to 12.50GHz, then 6.25GHz or 1.50GHz or even eliminate the ITU grid entirely, he says. Such an approach is dubbed flexible spectrum or a gridless network.

With such an approach, the optical transponders can tune the bit rate and the modulation format according to the reach and capacity requirements. The ROADMs or, more aptly, the wavelength-selective switches (WSSes) on which they are based, also have to support such gridless operation. 

WSS vendors Finisar and Nistica already support such a flexible spectrum approach, while JDS Uniphase has just announced it is readying its first products. Meanwhile US operator Verizon is cheerleading the industry to support gridless. "I'm sure Verizon is going to make this happen, as it did at 100 Gigabit," says Tomkos.

 

Spatial multiplexing

The simplest way to implement spatial multiplexing is to use several fibres in parallel. However, this is not cost-effective. Instead, what is being proposed is to create multi-core fibres - fibres that have more than one core - seven, 19 or more cores in an hexagonal arrangement, down which light can be transmitted. "That will increase the fibre's capacity by a factor of ten of 20," says Tomkos.

Another consideration is to move from single-mode to multi-mode fibre that will support the transmission of multiple modes, as many as several hundred. 

The issue with multi-mode fibre is its very high modal dispersion which limits its bandwidth-distance product. "Now with improved techniques from signal processing like MIMO [multiple-input, multiple out] processing, OFDM [orthogonal frequency division multiplexing] to more advanced optical technologies, you can think that all these multiple modes in the fibre can be used potentially as independent channels," says Tomkos. "Therefore you can potentially multiply your fibre capacity by 100x or 200x."  

The Proceedings of the IEEE issue will have a paper on flexible networking by NEC Labs, USA, and a second, on the ultimate capacity limits in optical communications, authored by Bell Labs.

 

Further reading:

MODE-GAP EU Seventh Framework project, click here


Privacy Preference Center